Can the mostly-empty space beneath the railroad tracks approaching Union Station become active spaces that enhance the NoMa neighborhood? The NoMa Business Improvement District (BID) hopes so. Some other cities have been able to activate underpasses; can these show the way?
The BID launched a design competition to find “an artist, team of artists, designer or architect” to “beautify, enliven and activate” the spaces under the tracks on Florida Avenue and K, L, and M Streets NE with a “sensory experience.”
"We want to turn those spaces into places that people want to come visit because they are so attractive and cool,” says Robin Eve-Jasper, president of NoMa BID.
Funding comes from the $50 million Mayor Gray recently authorized to help NoMa combat its dearth of parks. The DC Council still must approve the spending, but Eve-Jasper says that she expects this to happen by the end of May. Responses from design teams are due by May 9, with a plan to present proposals to the public in September and select a final design in October.
Underpasses get little activity today
Pedestrians currently use the underpasses as little more than empty zones to cross from one side of the tracks to the other.
M Street is the most active of the four, as it is the main access route to the NoMa-Gallaudet Metro station and the Metropolitan Branch Trail (MBT) for residents who live on the east side of the tracks. It also contains a Capital Bikeshare station on its northern sidewalk.
Neighborhood residents headed to NoMa’s main activity center at the corner of M and First Street NE, where there is a Harris Teeter supermarket, other stores and offices, also use the M Street underpass.
Cars dominate the Florida Ave and K Street underpasses, which dedicate six and four lanes to car traffic, respectively. Both streets have narrow sidewalks and see significantly less pedestrian traffic than M Street.
The L Street underpass is the least used of the four, according to my observations. It has wide sidewalks and only two lanes for cars — like M Street — but lacks easy access to the Metro or the MBT, and the activity center of its sibling a block north.
Other cities have activated underpasses
Highway underpasses have become public space in a number of other cities. Many include basketball courts, bike trails, skate parks and play areas for children.
Underpass Park in Toronto, located under the western end of the Eastern Avenue overpass near the Don River, is a widely-cited example. A recent Architectural Record report found the park’s basketball courts and skate park popular among area residents, but the children’s area was less so.
The article also noted that an art installation called Mirage, which includes reflective panels that add light to the underpass, does provide some illumination but adds that more mirrors would have brightened the space.
Other examples include Burnside Skatepark in Portland, Oregon and I-5 Colonnade Mountain Bike Park in Seattle, both of which are under overpasses.
The underpasses in NoMa lack the height and depth of many of these spaces. This makes it difficult to fit amenities like basketball courts or skate parks, though a linear children’s play area could fit on either L or M Streets.
Chicago’s Hyde Park neighborhood may offer some of the closest examples to the spaces in NoMa. A number of underpasses under a Metra rail line through the neighborhood sport murals by local artists and some even have corner shops built into their corners.
Asked what NoMa BID envisions for the four spaces, Eve-Jasper says that she is leaving that up to the architects and designers to decide. What do you think would work best in the underpasses?